Abortion
is a much debated and controversial topic. What is the teaching
of the Catholic church on the matter?
Definition
Abortion
is the ejection of an immature and non-viable foetus from the
womb of a woman. When this happens naturally there can be no grounds
for any sort of moral judgement. Where the abortion is 'procured'
that is, done directly or caused to happen, then, the Catholic
Church says that, a grave moral wrong is committed.
History
From
the earliest times the Church has condemned abortion. One of the
earliest statements condemning abortion is recorded in a document
called the Didache, written in the 2nd century A.D. According
to it: "You shall not kill the embryo by abortion and shall
not cause the newborn to perish".
The
teaching has been repeated through the centuries and as early
as the 4th century the Church made abortion a crime with its own
proper penalties. In the 16th century, Popes Sixtus V and Gregory
XIV said that causing or having an abortion means that the guilty
person is automatically excommunicated (cut off from the Church).
This position is clearly stated again in the Church's own collection
of laws (the Code of Canon Law, 1983): "A person who actually
procures an abortion incurs automatic excommunication" (Canon
1398).
Why?
The
Church says that human life begins when the woman's egg is fertilized
by a male sperm. From that moment a unique life begins, altogether
different from the life of the mother and of the father. The features
which distinguish it from it’s parents - the colour of the
eyes, the shape of the face, etc. - are all laid down in the "genetic
code" that comes into existence then. Each new life that
begins at this point is not a potential human being but a human
being with potential. No one can point to the twelfth day or the
fourth week or any other time and say, "This is when I began
being me." The process of life begins at conception while
birth is only the end point of the life within the womb of the
mother.
The right to life
The
Catholic Church takes a stand against all practices that degrade
human rights and dignity. It’s opposition to abortion comes
from a recognition of the basic rights of all individuals. These
individuals include the unborn, who have their own due importance.
They also have rights which cannot be taken away from them. One
such right is the right to life.
The
'Catechism of the Catholic Church' (1992) states that the embryo
must be treated from conception as a person (n. 2274) and it stresses
that the inalienable right to life of every innocent human individual
is a constitutive element of a civil society and its legislation.
The
Catechism quotes from the document 'Donum Vitae' ('The gift of
life') from the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the
Faith (the office that deals with matters of faith and morals).
That document says: "The inalienable rights of the person
must be recognized and respected by civil society and the political
authority. These human rights depend neither on single individuals
nor on parents; nor do they represent a concession made by the
society and the state; they belong to human nature and are inherent
in the persons by virtue of the creative act from which the person
took his origin. Among such fundamental rights one should mention
in this regard every human being's right to life ... from the
moment of conception until death."
In
other words, a person does not have a right to life because someone
gives him/her that right. The person has the right to live because
he/she is a human being, and a human being from the moment of
conception. As no-one can give him/her that right, no-one can
take it away also.
The
same argument applies in the case of euthanasia. Nobody has the
right to take away the gift of life from an old or sick person,
even if that person appears to have given consent or expressed
a desire to be put to death. The Church says that "ordinary"
means of preserving life should be used in the case of irreversibly
or terminally ill people, but "extraordinary" means
are not demanded. This is especially true when treatment may be
difficult or painful and have no lasting effect.
In
other words, if a person is clearly soon going to die, medical
care may be withdrawn and that person be allowed to die naturally.
In all cases, treatment for pain relief should be given, since
this is considered as "ordinary". Food and water are
not medical treatment and withdrawing them from a terminally ill
person is wrong and actually causes death.
Recent
formal teaching of the Pope
In
1995, Pope John Paul II wrote an encyclical letter (a teaching
letter to the whole Catholic Church) called 'Evangelium Vitae'
(Latin for 'The Gospel of Life'). In that he deals with three
major 'life' issues, abortion, euthanasia and the destruction
of human embryos in medical research. He also touches briefly
on issues like suicide and the death penalty. The letter repeats
very clearly the Catholic Church's position on abortion.
The
basic principle stated is: "I confirm that the direct and
voluntary killing of an innocent human being is always gravely
immoral" (EV n. 57). This principle applies to all the aforesaid
cases. The principle admits that accidental and even indirect
killing is not always wrong, and that legitimate self-defense
can sometimes cause death.
The
Pope calls abortion murder, saying that we need now more than
ever to have the courage to look things in the eye and call things
by their proper name. He acknowledges the tragedy that abortion
can often be for the mother, and the emotional suffering it might
cause her. The decision is often not made for selfish reasons,
but to protect things like her own health or the living standards
of the rest of the family. Sometimes there is a fear that the
conditions into which the child is to be born are so bad that
it is better that the child is not born. Nevertheless, these reasons
and others like them, however serious and tragic, can never justify
the deliberate killing of an innocent human being (EV n. 58).
|